The purity requested is rarely the purity needed
Most plants specify a higher nitrogen purity than their process requires, and pay for the difference in energy every day of the year. The origin is usually historical:
- Legacy of liquefied gas. Cryogenic nitrogen reaches 99.999 % by the very nature of how it is made. After years of liquid supply, that figure is assumed to be a process requirement when it was just a feature of the supplier.
- A “just in case” margin. When in doubt, a nine is added. Nobody has measured what happens to the product with one nine fewer.
- Confusing gas with result. What protects the product is the residual oxygen in the pack, the tank or the working atmosphere, and that figure depends on more factors than gas purity.
With liquid supply, over-specification does not show on the invoice. With on-site PSA generation, purity is a design variable and every tenth has a measurable cost. This article explains how much it costs and how to set the right purity.
What purity really measures
In a PSA generator, purity is expressed as 100 % minus residual oxygen. The argon in air, also inert, accompanies the nitrogen and is counted with it. The figure worth working with is therefore residual oxygen.
Three ways of saying the same thing
- 99.5 % equals 0.5 % residual O₂ (5,000 ppm) and grade 2.5.
- 99.9 % equals 1,000 ppm residual O₂ and grade 3.0.
- 99.999 % equals 10 ppm residual O₂ and grade 5.0.
Between 99.5 % and 99.999 % there is a factor of 500 in residual oxygen. Few processes need to travel that distance.
Purity is not the only quality parameter
Very pure nitrogen that is wet or carries traces of oil is not fit for food or electronics. The complete specification includes dew point, oil content and particles, defined by the ISO 8573-1 classes.
Usual purity by application
Most industrial uses of nitrogen are covered between 95 % and 99.9 %. The table shows the usual ranges and the criterion that sets the requirement in each case.
| Application | Usual purity | What sets the requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Chemical inerting and explosion prevention | 95–99 % | Limiting oxygen concentration of the product, with its safety margin |
| Modified atmosphere packaging | 99–99.9 % | Acceptable residual oxygen in the pack; legal minimum of 99 % (additive E 941) |
| Wineries: inerting, racking and bottling | 99.5–99.9 % | Acceptable dissolved oxygen in the wine |
| Pharmaceutical industry | ≥ 99.995 % | European Pharmacopoeia: content ≥ 99.5 % and O₂ ≤ 50 ppm; the oxygen limit governs |
| Electronics: wave and reflow soldering | 99.9–99.98 % | Acceptable residual oxygen in the oven |
| Laser cutting | 99.9–99.98 % | Material, thickness and edge finish; oxide-free stainless needs the upper band |
These are indicative ranges: the final figure is set by each process and must be validated with measurements. Applications requiring residual oxygen of a few ppm are the exception and need a specific study.
The packaging case
In modified atmosphere packaging, residual oxygen in the pack depends more on the packing machine's flushing efficiency than on the last tenth of gas purity. Going from 99.5 % to 99.9 % lowers the oxygen in the gas by 0.4 percentage points; poor flushing can leave several percent in the pack. Before asking for more purity, measure where it is being lost.
What each “nine” costs
To produce 1 Nm³ of nitrogen, a PSA generator uses between 2 and 5 Nm³ of compressed air, depending on purity. That ratio is the air factor, and the compressor's energy depends on it.
| Pureza | Residual O₂ | Air factor (Nm³ air / Nm³ N₂) | Energy (kWh/Nm³) | Energy versus 99.5 % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 95 % | 5 % | 1.9 | 0.21 | −37 % |
| 99 % | 1 % | 2.6 | 0.29 | −13 % |
| 99.5 % | 0.5 % | 3.0 | 0.33 | reference |
| 99.9 % | 1,000 ppm | 3.5 | 0.39 | +17 % |
| 99.98 % | 200 ppm | 4.7 | 0.52 | +57 % |
Indicative values for a PSA generator with carbon molecular sieve at 7–8 bar and a compressor at 0.11 kWh per Nm³ of air. They vary with the manufacturer, sieve condition, pressure and temperature.
Three readings of the table
- The curve is not linear. Going from 99 % to 99.5 % costs 15 % more energy; going from 99.9 % to 99.98 %, 34 % more.
- The savings margin is large. Going down from 99.98 % to 99.5 % cuts energy by 36 %.
- Purity is also capacity. The same generator delivers more flow at lower purity, so adjusting the specification can avoid an expansion.
Example: 150,000 Nm³ a year
With electricity at €0.12/kWh, a plant with this consumption saves each year:
- From 99.98 % to 99.5 %: 28,050 kWh and €3,366.
- From 99.9 % to 99.5 %: 8,250 kWh and €990.
The saving repeats over the whole life of the equipment. In a new installation there is also the lower investment in a smaller generator and compressor.
How to determine the purity your process needs
The right purity is the minimum that guarantees product quality with a defined safety margin. It is determined by measuring, in four steps:
- Identify the critical parameter. It is not the gas purity but its effect: residual oxygen in the pack, dissolved oxygen in the wine, oxidation of the cut edge or soldering defects.
- Measure the current situation. With a calibrated analyser, record residual oxygen at the point of use and the critical parameter in the product.
- Test at lower purity. Lower purity in steps and check the critical parameter at each one. The first step that changes it marks the process limit.
- Set the setpoint with a margin and monitor it. Set the specification one step above the limit and monitor it continuously.
The non-negotiable minimums
- Food: 99 % minimum, as it is the additive E 941 (Regulation (EU) No 231/2012).
- Pharma: the European Pharmacopoeia “Nitrogen” monograph requires a content ≥ 99.5 %, but also O₂ ≤ 50 ppm, CO₂ ≤ 300 ppm, CO ≤ 5 ppm and water ≤ 67 ppm. With a PSA generator, the oxygen limit means working at 99.995 % or above.
- Explosive atmospheres: purity follows from the product's limiting oxygen concentration and the margin set in the explosion protection document (ATEX).
Conclusion: specify what your process needs
Purity is the design decision that weighs most on a nitrogen plant's energy consumption, and it can almost always be adjusted. Specifying with measured data rather than inherited figures cuts energy per Nm³ and frees generator capacity without compromising product quality.
Keeping that setpoint means monitoring it. Our GAS4U platform continuously monitors purity and pressure, and detects deviations before they reach the product.
Do you know what purity your process really needs? Ask for a free energy audit and we will determine it with measurements at your plant.
Request an audit →